Sunday, November 18, 2012

The first Thanksgiving at Plymouth





It's interesting to learn how people dressed long ago, but that subject sometimes can’t be separated from history in general. And so before talking about what the Pilgrims wore for the three-day feast that eventually became known as Thanksgiving, let me set the stage by sharing an account of the event by Edward Winslow.
  
Our harvest being gotten in, our governour sent foure men on fowling, that so we might after a speciall manner rejoyce together, after we had gathered the fruits of our labours ; they foure in one day killed as much fowle, as with a little helpe beside, served the Company almost a weeke, at which time amongst other Recreations, we exercised our Armes, many of the Indians coming amongst us, and amongst the rest their greatest king Massasoyt, with some ninetie men, whom for three dayes we entertained and feasted, and they went out and killed five Deere, which they brought to the Plantation and bestowed on our Governour, and upon the Captaine and others."

The famous painting by Jennie A. Brownscombe, shown above, depicts the first Thanksgiving, but it was painted in 1914 and is therefore an artist’s rendering that can’t be taken literally. So, how do we know what the Pilgrims were decked out in when they celebrated their first successful harvest? Few items the Pilgrims wore still exist, but they would have dressed in the same fashion as people in England at that time. Obviously there were different cloaks for different folks, but we have very few visual records to guide us. Virtually all paintings of that era are of the aristocracy to which the Pilgrims did not belong.
We are, however, able to paint a fairly accurate picture of the Plymouth feast where attire is concerned. Pilgrim wills and inventories describing articles of clothing are a start. In addition, The Mayflower passenger list shows several of the Pilgrims came to America with servants. This points to some of them having been of the Middle Class - skilled tradesmen and merchants. Fortunately for the fashion researcher, there is enough from that period in museum collections to give an idea of how the English Middle Class dressed.

An article by Duane A. Cline at http://rootsweb.ancestry.com/~mosmd/index.htm also gives us insight into the social status of the Pilgrims. “The Pilgrims were certainly knowledgeable of fabrics and clothing construction. In looking at the occupations of the Pilgrims we find that Isaac Allerton and James Chilton were tailors, William Bradford was a fustian-maker, Edward Tilley was a cloth-maker, John Tilley was a silk worker, Francis Cooke and William White were wool combers or carders, and Digory Priest had been a hatter in London. In addition to those clothing-related trades we know that William Mullins was a boot and shoe merchant, and Thomas Rogers was a camlet merchant.

Putting the pieces together, we realize Pilgrim clothes were not as drab as myth would have us think. 1621 was the early Baroque period when the Cavalier style was all the rage. Although the flamboyant colors and extravagant details of high society fashion would have been somewhat toned down by Middle Class and Puritan conservatism, Pilgrim attire would have conformed to the style of the day by and large. Women’s dresses would have had shaped bodices and flowing skirts over petticoats. Men would have worn short, fitted jackets called doublets and breeches or pantaloons which ended below the knee. The rest of the leg would have been covered only by hose, except when the knee-high bucket top boots of the day were worn. Both men and women wore the popular falling ruff, a wide circular collar that fell on the shoulders and opened in a V.

As I imagine the assembly of Pilgrims for that first Thanksgiving, I see men in beaver hats with cocked brims sitting around a long table. There is a man wearing a red waistcoat, which stands out in contrast to the otherwise subdued colors worn by the group. Another has a violet velvet cloak lined with taffeta draped over his shoulders. Peeking out from beneath the skirt of the woman sitting next to him is a pair of lace-trimmed, pointed slippers that match her embroidered cap. Across the table from her, another woman wears a dress with a white ruff and sleeves with wide cuffs. She, like many women in the group, wears an apron. Although they are hidden from view, her stockings are held with garters, which unlike ours today, are long, wide ribbons wrapped several times around her upper calves before being tied securely in a bow.

On the right we see what the Pilgrims likely wore. But how did Chief Massasoit of the Wampanoag and his entourage of ninety men dress for the occasion, I wonder? Having not read the full texts of the Pilgrims' journals for their first year at Plymouth, I can only surmise. One account describes Massasoit when the Pilgrims first saw him in March, 1621. “The great chief first appeared at the head of 60 warriors, face painted red and wearing a thick necklace of white beads, the sign of his authority.” This account makes no mention of clothes, but it’s safe to assume the Wampanoag were wearing suits of deerskin for their visit to the Pilgrims in March and again for the feast that would become one of America's most loved traditions.

Image of "The First Thanksgiving at Plymouth" by Jennie A. Brownscombe courtesy of Pilgrim Hall Museum, Plymouth. http://www.pilgrimhall.org/f_thanks.htm

10 comments:

  1. Interesting post to lead us into the holiday. Happy Thanksgiving!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Adriene. Happy Thanksgiving to you too!

      Delete
  2. Simply fascinating to me, half a world away (Australia) and only able to dream of the family reunions and sumptuous dinners coming up all over the US. Wish I was there. Happy Thanksgiving :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Fabulous to have a visitor all the way from Australia! Thanks so much for your comment. Will think of you when the turkey gets carved on Thursday. Last year my birthday fell on Thanksgiving so it was a double celebration.

      Delete
  3. So interesting considering we were always taught that the pilgrims were very dowdy and plain, I like this much better!!! But am curious about the Indians, must have had some sort of clothing as the northeast is very cold in the winter.
    Once again Joan, you have taught me and intrigued me. Happy Turkey Day to you and yours!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for joining the conversation Anonymous, and for bringing up the point about what the Indians wore. Some of the old etchings portraying them showed them wearing deerskin suits. You're right. It would have been pretty nippy at that time of year, so no doubt that is what they were wearing. Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours too!

      Delete
  4. This was such a fun post. It was funny because the painting from 1914 is just as I was raised to visualize The First thanksgiving and you have made me imagine it in a far more fun light! I hope your Turkey is delicious and that you are surrounded by LOVE , Peace and Light.
    http://thebridgeofdeaths.tumblr.com/
    MCV Egan

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Maybe it's because of that painting we all envisioned people dressed like that for the first Thanksgiving (: It's probably the most famous of Thanksgiving paintings. May your turkey be delicious too - and may you also be surrounded by love, peace and light. What a beautiful wish. Thanks so much!

      Delete
  5. Very interesting. To be honest, I don't think much about the orgiins of Thanksgiving, though I've been forced to lately as my elementary school kids are learning about it. Wonderful post. I enjoy learning new tidbits!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for visiting, Sandra. This blog is a journey of discovery for me too. I'm learning all sorts of things I never knew before. Happy Thanksgiving!

      Delete